New Jersey Supreme Court Webcast

Case Resume

Case Resume
Text Color
Back Color

Device Sleep: N/AAllow SleepPrevent Sleep
Font
Font Size
Text Color
Back Color
Toggle White Space
Toggle Pause

Font
Font Size
Text Color
Back Color
Toggle White Space
Toggle Pause

Next webcast is scheduled for Monday, Oct. 20, 2025 and Tuesday, Oct. 21, 2025.

Oct. 20, 2025

10 a.m.
A-43-24 State v. Jeremy Arrington (090216) Can a criminal defendant advance an insanity defense under N.J.S.A. 2C:4-1 without expert testimony? Certification Granted Posted Argued Briefs: A-43-24 Petition for Certification A-43-24 Appellate Division Brief A-43-24 Appellate Division Pro Se Supplemental Brief A-43-24 Appellate Division Reply Brief A-43-24 Respondent Brief Letter A-43-24 Appellate Division Brief A-43-24 Supplemental Appellant Brief A-43-24 Supplemental Respondent Brief A-43-24 Gibbons PC Amicus Curiae Brief A-43-24 ACLU of New Jersey Amicus Curiae Brief A-43-24 Attorney General Amicus Curiae Brief
A-59-24 State v. Kader S. Mustafa (090329) Can a criminal defendant advance a diminished capacity defense under N.J.S.A. 2C:4-2 without expert testimony? Certification Granted Posted Argued Briefs: A-59-24 Petition for Certification A-59-24 Respondent Brief Letter A-59-24 Appellate Division Brief A-59-24 Supplemental Appellant Brief A-59-24 American Civil Liberties Union of New Jersey Amicus Curiae Brief Letter A-59-24 Attorney General Amicus Curiae Brief A-59-24 Gibbons PC Amicus Curiae Brief A-59-24 Appellant Response to Amicus Curiae Brief Letter

1 p.m.
A-46-24 In the Matter of Rutgers, the State University of New Jersey, and AFSCME Local 888 (090230) Does the grievance process for sexual harassment mandated by the federal government’s Title IX rules preempt the process set forth in the terms of a collective negotiations agreement that allows an employee to challenge their termination for just cause? Certification Granted Posted Argued Briefs: A-46-24 Petition for Certification A-46-24 Respondent Brief A-46-24 Beckett Paris LLC Respondent Brief A-46-24 Reply Brief A-46-24 Zazzali PC Amicus Curiae Brief A-46-24 Weissman & Mintz LLC Amicus Curiae Brief A-46-24 Attorney General Amicus Curiae Brief A-46-24 Sills Cummis & Gross Response to NJEA Amicus Curiae Brief A-46-24 Sills Cummis & Gross Response to Attorney General Amicus Curiae Brief A-46-24 Sills Cummis Response to American Federation of Teachers et al. Amicus Curiae Brief

Oct. 21, 2025

10 a.m.
A-68-24 In the Matter of the Verified Petition for the Proposed Creation of a PK-12 All-Purpose Regional School District (090182) Under N.J.S.A. 18A:13-47.11, does the Borough of Sea Bright have standing to withdraw from a merged school district with the Oceanport Board of Education and the Shore Regional High School District Board of Education to join the all-purpose regional Henry Hudson School District? Certification Granted Posted Argued Briefs: A-68-24 Petition for Certification A-68-24 Respondent Brief A-68-24 Respondent Brief Letter
A-47-24 State v. Gerald W. Butler (090237) Did the prosecutor’s reference to the television show The Wire in the opening statement; references to the Organized Crime Unit, gun violence, and trafficking in the City of Millville; and testimony that defendant was the target of a search warrant, individually or cumulatively amount to reversible error? Certification Granted Posted Argued Briefs: A-47-24 Petition for Certification Letter A-47-24 Respondent Brief Letter A-47-24 Appellate Division Brief A-47-24 Supplemental Appellant Brief A-47-24 Supplemental Respondent Brief A-47-24 American Civil Liberties Union of New Jersey Amicus Brief Letter A-47-24 Pashman Stein et al. Amicus Curiae Brief

1 p.m.
A-35-24 In the Matter of P.T. Jibsail Family Limited Partnership Tidelands License Number 1515-06-0012.1 TDI 190001 (089547) Does the Tidelands Resource Council have statutory authority to fix and modify pierhead lines through the issuance of individual licenses? Certification Granted Posted Argued Briefs: A-35-24 Petition for Certification A-35-24 Respondent Brief Letter A-35-24 Respondent Brief A-35-24 Reply Brief A-35-24 Amicus Curiae Brief Letter A-35-24 Supplemental Appellant Brief A-35-24 Supplemental Respondent Brief A-35-24 Attorney General Supplemental Brief

View the Supreme Court oral argument schedule for the 2025-2026 Court Year.

View the Supreme Court room seating diagram.

The NJ Judiciary will provide reasonable accommodations to enable individuals with disabilities to access and participate in court events. Interpreting services also will be provided if requested. Please contact SupremeCtADA.mbx@njcourts.gov to request an accommodation or interpreting services.

Recent webcast arguments can be found on the Recent Arguments page. Webcasts also are available, along with appeal summaries and other case-related information, on the Supreme Court Appeals page

We welcome your questions or feedback about the Supreme Court Webcasts. Please email us at
Webcast.Mailbox@njcourts.gov